6.1 KiB
| verdict | remediation_round |
|---|---|
| needs-attention | 0 |
Milestone Validation: M001
Success Criteria Checklist
| # | Criterion | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | cargo check passes on macOS, Linux, and Windows targets |
⚠️ Partial | macOS + Windows MSVC pass; Linux cross-compile blocked by missing x86_64-linux-gnu-gcc toolchain on Windows host (code review confirms #[cfg] guards correct, but no compilation proof) |
| 2 | Daemon started with --tcp 127.0.0.1:9876 accepts TCP connections and responds correctly |
❌ Missing | No live daemon start verified; S04 integration smoke test never executed due to auto-mode tools-policy blocker |
| 3 | Client with --tcp 127.0.0.1:9876 returns same results as local transport |
❌ Missing | S04 T02 (TCP vs local comparison) still pending; no real daemon round-trip verified |
| 4 | Client with --tcp 127.0.0.1:9999 (unreachable) fails with clear error within 15s |
✅ Pass | test_send_tcp_connection_refused integration test passes (S03); 15s connect timeout configured in send_tcp() |
| 5 | Commands without --tcp still work via local transport (no regression) |
✅ Pass | 35/35 tests pass including 32 pre-existing tests; S01 UAT covers local socket path |
Slice Delivery Audit
| Slice | Status | Summary | Tasks | Assessment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S01 | complete | ✅ Valid SUMMARY.md | 3/3 done | ✅ Transport traits + TCP server + cross-platform compile verified |
| S02 | complete | ✅ Valid SUMMARY.md | 3/3 done | ✅ TCP client transport + --tcp flag + daemon status/stop verified |
| S03 | complete | ✅ Valid SUMMARY.md | 2/2 done | ✅ Integration tests (mock server round-trip, connection refused, liveness) + 35/35 suite pass |
| S04 | complete ⚠️ | ❌ BLOCKER placeholder (auto-mode tools-policy rejection) | 1/2 done, 1 pending | ❌ Real e2e daemon-client TCP integration test never executed; SUMMARY is not valid evidence |
Cross-Slice Integration
S01 → S02: ✅ PASS — Transport traits (Listener/Connector), TcpListener, TcpConnector, handle_connection produced in S01; consumed in S02 to build client transport. Source artifacts confirmed via grep.
S01 → S03: ⚠️ FLAG — S03 frontmatter requires: slice S01 provides: (empty) — provides field blank, contract not documented. Artifacts exist and were tested, but dependency chain is opaque.
S02 → S03: ⚠️ FLAG — S03 frontmatter requires: slice S02 provides: (empty) — same documentation gap.
S02 → S04: ❌ FAIL — S04 SUMMARY is a blocker placeholder; T01 has no task summary; T02 still pending. No real daemon-client integration test written or executed.
S03 → S04: ❌ FAIL — S03 produced integration-tested TCP client (mock server), but S04 never consumed it for real binary-level testing.
Source verification confirmed: Listener trait, Connector trait, TcpListener, TcpConnector, handle_connection, send_tcp, is_alive_tcp, Start {} subcommand, --tcp flag, tcp_addr param, start_daemon — all present in source.
Requirement Coverage
| Requirement | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| R002 — TCP transport with timeouts, hard error, no silent fallback | COVERED | S02: send_tcp() with 15s connect/120s read-write timeout, hard error on failure. S03: 3 integration tests (round-trip, connection refused, liveness) + 35/35 suite pass + cross-platform compilation. |
| R004 — Global --tcp flag on Cli struct | COVERED | S02: tcp: Option<String> on Cli struct, wired through all 14 cmd_* functions. --tcp visible in CLI help. |
| R007 — ensure_daemon() hard-errors on TCP failure | COVERED | S02: ensure_daemon() hard-errors on TCP connection failure; send_tcp() returns Result; no silent fallback. |
All formally tracked requirements (R002, R004, R007) are covered at the unit/mock integration test level. However, the milestone-level e2e integration proof (S04) remains unexecuted.
Verification Class Compliance
| Class | Planned Check | Evidence | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contract | Transport traits defined, all three implementations compile, protocol handling is shared | Listener/Connector traits in src/transport/; TCP, Unix socket, Windows named pipe impls; cargo check passes native + Windows MSVC; handle_connection shared via generic function |
✅ Pass |
| Integration | Daemon listens on local + TCP simultaneously, client connects via TCP and gets correct response | S01: daemon wired for dual listen. S03: mock-server integration tests confirm send_tcp round-trip. S04 (real daemon-client integration) did not execute | ⚠️ Flag — partial; real e2e missing |
| Operational | Daemon starts with --tcp, handles bind errors cleanly, client fails with clear error when TCP unreachable |
ensure_daemon() hard-errors on TCP failure (S02); connection-refused test passes (S03). No evidence of bind error handling (port-in-use scenario) or clean shutdown behavior |
⚠️ Flag — partial; bind-error and shutdown untested |
| UAT | Manual smoke test: daemon on TCP + client queries return same data as local transport | S01–S03 UATs cover compilation, flag visibility, and mock tests. S04 UAT does not exist — the live daemon smoke test was never performed | ❌ Missing |
Verdict Rationale
All three slices S01–S03 are properly completed with valid summaries, passing tests, and cross-platform compilation. The core TCP transport implementation (traits, server, client, --tcp flag) is fully functional and verified at unit and mock-integration level. However, S04 — the end-to-end integration smoke test proving real daemon ↔ client communication over TCP — was never executed due to an auto-mode tools-policy blocker (planning-dispatch unit attempted to write source files). S04's SUMMARY.md is a placeholder, not valid evidence, and 1 of 2 tasks remains pending despite the DB marking the slice as "complete." This leaves the milestone's highest-level acceptance criterion (real TCP round-trip with actual wx binary) unverified. Verdict: needs-attention.